Blog //

88% of British businesses think they’re cyber resilient. The Bank of England has just given them a reason to think again.

Almost nine in ten British organisations believe their cyber resilience is above average. Statistically, that’s a remarkable level of confidence.

The problem is that much of it may be misplaced.

In NormCyber’s research involving 500 UK organisations, 88% rated their cyber resilience above average. Yet 60% reported that recovering from a cyber incident had taken longer than their resilience score suggested it would.

Businesses believe they’re prepared for a cyberattack, but their own experiences suggest otherwise.

Now, the Bank of England, Prudential Regulation Authority and Financial Conduct Authority have published proposed guidance on cyber risk and resilience management, as the financial sector faces a growing threat.

The timing said it all. October saw the second-highest monthly number of cyber incidents reported to the FCA in five years, 52% above the previous 18-month peak.

The regulators want financial firms to demonstrate that they can identify cyber risks, detect attacks, contain incidents and recover effectively.

But this raises a question that should concern every British business leader, not just those working in financial services. What if the cyber resilience we’re reporting to our boards isn’t resilience at all?

We’ve built an industry around measuring the wrong things.

For decades, the cyber security industry has encouraged businesses to invest in stronger defences. More sophisticated technology. More monitoring. More controls. More compliance.

And much of that investment has been essential. But somewhere along the way, we’ve started confusing security activity with business resilience.

We measure how many threats we’ve blocked, how many vulnerabilities we’ve fixed and how quickly we’ve responded to incidents. We present those numbers to boards as evidence that the organisation is becoming more secure.

Yet none of those metrics, in isolation, answers the question that matters most.

Can the business keep operating when something goes wrong?

A manufacturer can have world-class threat detection and still lose days of production. A retailer can pass every compliance assessment and still be unable to process payments. A housing association can have excellent security controls and still find itself unable to deliver essential services to residents.

The financial consequences can be substantial. But so can the damage to customers, employees, reputation and public trust.

And critically, an organisation may not discover the gap between its perceived resilience and its actual recovery capabilities until an attack has already succeeded.

That isn’t simply a technology problem. It’s a failure of business risk management.

The great cyber resilience hallucination.

At NormCyber, we call this disconnect the Cyber Resilience Hallucination. It’s what happens when reassuring dashboards, compliance certificates and positive security reports create a level of confidence that the underlying evidence cannot justify.

Our research suggests this is far from an isolated problem.

And it’s not necessarily because organisations are ignoring cyber security. Many are making substantial investments, employing skilled teams and taking their responsibilities seriously.

The problem is that they’re measuring the effectiveness of their security operations without necessarily measuring the resilience of their business.

Those are two very different things.

  • Blocking thousands of attacks is valuable. But what happens when one gets through?
  • Closing vulnerabilities is important. But which unresolved weaknesses could bring critical operations to a standstill?
  • Meeting compliance requirements is necessary. But does that mean the organisation could restore essential services within an acceptable timeframe?

Until businesses can answer those questions with evidence, confidence in their resilience may be little more than an educated guess.

The Bank of England is asking the right questions. Every board should be listening.

The latest regulatory consultation is significant because it reinforces the importance of understanding cyber risk across the organisation, including governance, critical infrastructure, dependencies, detection, response and recovery.

It also aligns with established frameworks, including the National Cyber Security Centre’s Cyber Assessment Framework.

The proposals apply to firms within existing financial-sector operational resilience requirements, but the principles behind them are relevant to businesses of every size and sector.

Because a cyberattack doesn’t care whether an organisation is regulated by the FCA. And business disruption doesn’t become less damaging simply because it happens outside financial services.

The challenge now is to turn those principles into something meaningful at board level.

Not another annual assessment. Not another compliance checklist. And certainly not another dashboard that tells directors everything is green without explaining what that actually means for the business.

Boards need a consistent, evidence-led understanding of their resilience, how it is changing and where weaknesses could threaten critical operations.

Why isn’t cyber resilience measured like every other business KPI?

Consider how businesses manage financial performance.

No credible board would accept an annual snapshot of revenue, profitability or cash flow as sufficient evidence that the organisation was performing well.

Directors expect regular reporting. They want to see trends, understand what is driving change and identify problems before they become crises.

Yet when it comes to cyber resilience, many organisations still rely on periodic assessments and backward-looking reports. It’s an extraordinary inconsistency.

Cyber incidents can directly affect revenue, productivity, customer service, regulatory obligations and ultimately business survival. So why isn’t resilience measured with the same rigour as the other indicators that determine organisational performance?

Cyber resilience should be a standard business KPI.

At NormCyber, we believe cyber reseilence should be continuously measured, consistently reported and connected to the organisation’s ability to maintain its most important operations.

That requires bringing together evidence across people, processes and technology, rather than treating each security discipline as an isolated measure of success.

It means understanding where resilience is strong, where it is deteriorating and whether investment is delivering measurable improvement.

And it means giving boards something they can act on, rather than simply something they can take comfort from.

The most expensive cyber risk could be false confidence

The real danger isn’t necessarily that British businesses are spending too little on cyber security. It’s that they may be spending significant sums without knowing whether those investments are making them more resilient.

That distinction matters, because when a board believes its organisation is adequately protected, it makes decisions accordingly. Investment is directed elsewhere. Risks are accepted. Weaknesses remain unresolved.

And when a serious incident occurs, the business discovers whether its reported resilience was an accurate reflection of reality or simply a reassuring collection of metrics.

The Bank of England and FCA’s consultation should therefore be seen as more than another regulatory development. It’s an opportunity to challenge how we define, measure and govern cyber resilience across British business.

We need to stop asking boards to take comfort from the number of threats blocked and start giving them evidence that their organisations can withstand disruption.

Because a green dashboard won’t keep a factory running. A compliance certificate won’t restore a payment system. And an impressive security report won’t guarantee that customers can continue accessing essential services.

The next time a board is told its organisation is cyber resilient, someone should ask a simple question:

“Can you prove it?”

If the answer is no – that isn’t resilience.

It’s confidence. And the two should never be confused.

Download The Cyber Resilience Hallucination to explore the complete findings from 500 UK organisations.